Need an honest opinion

[nesurf]

Hey guys.


I am contemplating purchasing a sweet potato/baked potato. The shapes look amazing!

However, I am concerned about the firewire technology. I have heard about horror stories with these boards snapping under very strange circumstance, like duckdiving a small wave, by multiple people.

I would appreciate if someone/anyone could watch this video, read the comments for further info regarding these potential problems, and comment here about how the technology performs.

This is a big investment for me and I want it to last a long time. These boards look amazing but I have fear about the technology from these stories. I understand boards break but these stories seem to break in strange ways and are consistent enough to make me consider going the tried and true PU route.

So please, help is needed and I'd appreciate honest comments.


Thanks. I hope this works out and I hop on a potato soon.

[buzzy]

I don't see a video there but I own 2 firewire boards, having had one for probably 3 years now and the other for around 9 months, and I haven't had any problems with them. The only "issue" I have had is when my knee cracked the deck of one board, which I repaired pretty much like you'd repair any board, and it's been fine since.

I like the boards well enough I have a third on order, and if my local shaper did his boards in epoxy I'd order my boards from him in that tech as well.

[Goanna]

I've had four now and not one single issue at all.
Nesurf have you heard the bad stories down at the local or read them here on the Firewire forum?
I'm guessing you may have seen comments here on the forum and it is an easy perception to take when all the complaints are in the same place - where else can you see the good the bad and the ugly? (at least Firewire are putting themselves in the firing line)
Add up the complaints here and then add up all the good things said here about Firewire.
Add up all the snapped boards and then add up all the Firewires sold and I think you'll find the % ratio very low for the negative

I'll put it to you this way....If I ever snap my Firewire, I'll go get another one - the stoke this tech has given me far outweighs the cost

So get out there and grab one nesurf - cause at the moment you're missing out!

[nesurf]

My bad, I totally forgot the link. Here it is for the video...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsjsYcZqykA


That helps a lot, thanks. But yes, I have heard the complaints only in online forums, including firewire's (which I give huge respect for not policing and taking negative comments down). My local shop praises them and the guys there seem to be using the boards as well.

Again, the shapes look awesome and I am demoing one tomorrow am. My only concern is I'm quite broke and I want this investment to last 5+ years. I don't expect a ding proof board or anything like that but I've just heard about snappings and delams that make me nervous.

From what I can gather, the snappings appear to happen more frequently with the old FST boards with valves on them. I cannot gather whether the delams occur with FST rapidfire or any other specific technology, however I have heard the rapidfire bamboo layer soaks up water quickly if theres a ding. My concern is if I get a ding mid-session that I don't notice, I don't want my board to soak up water and get ruined from one ding.

Have to run, but any thoughts?


Also, Sweet potato/baked potato vs Dwart... any comments?

[iggy]

My bad, I totally forgot the link. Here it is for the video...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsjsYcZqykA


That helps a lot, thanks. But yes, I have heard the complaints only in online forums, including firewire's (which I give huge respect for not policing and taking negative comments down). My local shop praises them and the guys there seem to be using the boards as well.

Again, the shapes look awesome and I am demoing one tomorrow am. My only concern is I'm quite broke and I want this investment to last 5+ years. I don't expect a ding proof board or anything like that but I've just heard about snappings and delams that make me nervous.

From what I can gather, the snappings appear to happen more frequently with the old FST boards with valves on them. I cannot gather whether the delams occur with FST rapidfire or any other specific technology, however I have heard the rapidfire bamboo layer soaks up water quickly if theres a ding. My concern is if I get a ding mid-session that I don't notice, I don't want my board to soak up water and get ruined from one ding.

Have to run, but any thoughts?


Also, Sweet potato/baked potato vs Dwart... any comments?

As he mention it in the video that is HIS PERSONAL OPINION.
Have owned 9 fire wires already ranging all models:from longboards to sweet potatoes and yet to experience anything negative with mines.
The issue with many people is that sometimes people is under the impression that the boards are indestructible and they tend to push their own limits and put the boards on situations where regular PU boards would have not stand a chance...repeatedly.
Be assure that you will be acquiring a highly engineered product backed up with the best customer service in the market

[Goanna]

I've only had the Sweet Potato and it is an fun, fun board - you will be giggling like a maniac after some sessions on this board - or is that just me?
I haven't ridden the Baked Pot but I'm confident in saying you'll get the same level of delirium.

Nesurf I think you are worrying a bit too much - your concerns are understandable but if the wave is going to snap a Firewire, it was going to snap the PU as well.
Think positive thoughts my friend, save your pennies and you will reap the rewards - my mates and I all ride Firewires and agree that they will add 20% more enjoyment to all aspects of your surfing.

The strongest advice I can give you is to demo and then demo some more until you know what one works best for you - and then the rest will be history!

[buzzy]

All boards can snap and a PU board is more likely to do so.

Good luck with the decision making!

[Fritzkat]

Hmmm, I own 3 firewires and on to a fourth, no complaints here and I have dinged at least two of them and I repaired them. That guy in the video may have an honest complaint in his eyes, however, lets break it down, he surfed it for 6 months , hmmm maybe he stressed the board unknowingly in one of those 6 month sessions? Geesh he must have been an Angel from Heaven with Tender loving care to that board for 6 months, never duck dove it, pushed its limits or anything , then he broke it on a 3 foot day duck diving. So for over 6 months he never had a problem with the board? Sounds alot like there was already a fracture occuring he was unaware of and it finally snapped that day. A board can only take so much stress, PU and or EPS. I dont know him or his surf adventures, but I have personally snapped a PU board on a three foot day duck diving. I repaired the broken board and broke it another 2 times until it finally broke in another spot, stripping the glass clean off.. Its now retired forever. It was a Local Motion Rawson, which I loved. BUT, Did I call Rawson and bitch at him for his glassing job. Hell no, Did I call Local motion for the glassing job and complain that it should have lasted longer?.. Hell No. Is the Guy in the video expecting a little too much after surfing the board for 6 months ???. you be the judge.. I would have more empathy for him if it were the first go out, but he has had plenty of sessions to weaken the structure of the board unknowingly.

nesurf, are you honestly expecting any board to last 5 years? THEN, (sarcasm) you better get one with a triple 1/4 inch stringer, 12 ounces of glass on each side and a 12 ounce patch and glass in fins, and just forget any EPS or standard off the shelf PU board. forget light or super light PU blanks and 1.5 pound EPS foam. Do you want to surf? or just hang the board on the wall and watch it get yellow? Sorry for the (SARCASM) , but truly expecting a board to last 5 years is not realistic if you surf frequently. Your lucky if it (any board) lasts a year and breaks in half in the right spot so you can repair it on your own in your home backyard.

You may want to stick with FST if Rapidfire worries you. The new FST are valveless.. Good luck...
surf board rawson broken.jpg

[surferireland]

NESURF - My brother and I have had many different firewire boards over the last few years, we've surfed them in triple over head in ireland and didnt have any issues, I find the FST construction more resilient compared a standard light performance glass job. The sweet potato is short fat and wide and you will be hard pushed to snap one. We managed to snap a 6'0 dominator in just overhead (3ft) heavy beachbreak, boards do break even the firewire boards, but not all boards feel as good as the firewire boards. Get a board look after it, treat it like a ming vase on land, in the water try to destroy it, and rock on.

[prjwebb]

If you dry out any dings and repair them properly, that stops the core strength from becoming compromised and they'll last you a long time. I have FWs that are around two years old and still going great. I think if you look after your boards and don't put yourself into dodgy situations when surfing you could get that 5 years out of a FW.
If you like pushing your luck pulling into shallow, heavy closeout barrels and are a bit careless or reckless with your boards and don't take care of any knocks you pick up along the way then it's probable that you won't be getting those 5 years out of any board.